Scoresheets; Yours to keep

This may be hard to believe but once upon a time I was a bad barista. Yeh, I know.

In order to redress the situation I began pestering people with questions, anecdotes and theories in the hope that they’d pass on their hard-earned knowledge. In most cases, they did.

One such person was Stephen Morrissey, who one day did something very simple for me which made a huge impact on how I approached competition, my job and everything that followed after. He showed me his scoresheets.

Now, at the time Stephen was the incumbent World Barista Champion and one of the biggest name in coffee. I on the other hand was petrified by talk of dosing, extraction and latte art and was in complete awe of the baristas I watched online and in the busy cafes of London. I was weeks away from competing at my first WBC and felt enormously out of my depth.

Stephen’s very selfless act helped me in a lot of ways, but mostly because it demystified the job of a barista. He showed me the video of his performance and talked me through the scores. He cringed at the points lost, pointed out his errors (a farm called Guatemala?) and pretty much showed me that he was human after all.

It would have been easier to keep the scoresheets to himself and go along with the idealistic opinion I had of him that day but he chose not to. In truth, despite laying bear all his shortcomings, my estimation of him grew.

In later months I was lucky enough to bear witness to a handful of other baristas scoresheets and each time I got the chance I lapped them up taking mental notes and learning lessons like they were maps through a mine field.

I have therefore decided to pass on this kind gesture and publish my scoresheets so other aspiring baristas can see the anatomy of a competition run and also reveal the glaring errors that I made along the way.

Another reason I have decided to do this is perhaps slightly more delicate a discussion to have and that is the topic of transparency. Anyone who’s ever been associated with barista competitions knows that there has always, regrettably, been a murmuring of collusion, bias and argument associated with the scoring. I, for the record, believe no such clandestine behaviour is at play.

I’ve always felt that however unwaranted this wink-and-elbow whispering is, it is perhaps the fault of the organisers for conducting scoring in such a secretive way. We all know the scores of the competitors so why not reveal how they got those scores and who gave them? The current set-up does nothing short of arousing suspicion and invite criticism.

My finals video (slightly chopped) can be found here and the previous rounds are easily found if you follow the links. The pdf scoresheets are posted below so please download, watch and learn from my mistakes. I will also be delighted to field any questions you may have.

Finally I would also urge other competition baristas to follow suit and post your own scoresheets. If we are to move forward as an industry I firmly believe that disclosure, transparency and the sharing of knowledge is the key to our mutual success.

FINALS Ireland-Colin Harmon-HeadRD

FINALS Ireland-Colin Harmon-TechDM

FINALS Ireland-Colin Harmon-TechMY

FINALS Ireland-Colin Harmon-SensMM

FINALS Ireland-Colin Harmon-SensJG

FINALS Ireland-Colin Harmon-SensSH

FINALS Ireland-Colin Harmon-SensAP

About these ads

18 thoughts on “Scoresheets; Yours to keep

  1. Tim Styles says:

    Stephen has made everyone watch the video. He carries it, in various formats, on a USB flash drive medallion.

  2. michael mc laughlin says:

    great post, brilliant idea, would love to see more of this, i seen mine on the day and found it very very helpful, nice to see the standard i should aim to be getting at. hopefully this will go some way to helping those that just watch understand how much work is put in to prepping for competition and just how much scrutiny a barista is under when they are up there.

    great post col

  3. michael mc laughlin says:

    plus i really really want a usb flash drive medallion

  4. michael mc laughlin says:

    this may become the best thread ever, kenny loggins!

  5. [...] you should, as it’s excellent – will have noticed that Colin has uploaded his WBC scoresheets for all to see [...]

  6. [...] response to Colin Harmon’s excellent post on the sharing of information, and the inherent value in doing so, Gwilym Davies – World [...]

  7. boong says:

    Tim Varney got 7 in taste balance for Sig Drink!!!

  8. Keith Mrotek says:

    First Off.

    Awesome!!

    This is excellent!

    From the perspective of a Barista considering competition, this is super insightful!

    From a Barista who has judged Barista competition, I’m excited to see what this does to the scrutiny of judges in the future.

    Honestly. Nothing personal to anyone involved in the SCAA, or other involved parties. I was a technical judge for the Great Lakes Regional Barista Competition. I’ve never judged, or competed before. I didn’t feel qualified, to say the least, and I judged Michael Phillips, who went on to be World Barista Champion.

    I don’t mean to complain about the current setup of Barista Competition in the states, but rather to explain my excitement for the possibility of bringing out more qualified/scrutinized judges.

    I think this is a good thing.

    Thanks Colin!

  9. [...] great guy who goes by the name of Colin Harmon.  He just a bit ago made the genius decision to share his score sheets from competition with the world and was soon followed in suit by James Hoffman and [...]

  10. oneshotfortheroad says:

    Now all we need is some nerdy computer type to start up a web site to consolidate all of these on! My finals sheets if you like…

    http://oneshotfortheroad.wordpress.com/2010/09/30/catching-up/

  11. Wolfram says:

    The scoresheets from Thomas Schweiger from Germany can be found at http://www.radical-coffee.de, Tom made it to the semis.

  12. [...] WBC-Scoresheet 2010 von Collin Harmon, Irland [...]

  13. Mie says:

    Collin! You are so cool. I’m really respect you. And I told about this to all my colleagues.

  14. [...] Colin Harmon (Irish Champion, Finalist 2010, Pelopor) [...]

  15. [...] first, does it? Nonetheless, reading these WBC finals scoresheets from amazing baristas including Colin Harmon (he deserves all the respect for releasing his sheets first), Michael Phillips, James Hoffman and [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 171 other followers

%d bloggers like this: